Question: Have you ever disagreed with what your editor commented about your story? Do you follow all their comments?

I’ve been getting questions sent to me through email, Wattpad, and I think I’ll discuss some of them here on the blog too.

I’ve worked with at least five editors (and a few more beta readers) since I began writing and publishing, and yes, it still happens that I disagree with their comments. Sometimes. 🙂 I cave of course to anything factual, grammar-related, or lapses in logic in my story. Those I definitely work on, immediately.

Sometimes the comments or suggestions are what some people would consider subjective. More of, there’s nothing wrong with what I wrote, but the editor thinks it should be done another way. Based on her experience, knowledge, and instinct, she’s probably right. When I get these, I start thinking as a publisher, and evaluate what’s best for the book, and will this change help the book meet the goals I have for it. I appreciate when an editor makes me push a little more, and recognizes when I backed out of writing a scene out of fear or laziness. It helps me a lot, and that’s why they’re there, and so valuable.

The times when I put my foot down and defy an editor’s comment is when I know this is what I want to do, and it will be done this particular way. When that happens I take responsibility for the story, all of it, even the “bad parts.” I must warn you though, this is usually a risk, and you could lose readers and buyers if you’re too risky. But I feel this is something I need to do sometimes, so I know what’s possible.

Here’s how I answered this on

No comments

Leave a Reply

Another way to thank me (if you found any of this helpful)


About Mina

Mina V. Esguerra writes and publishes romance novels. She founded #RomanceClass, a community of Filipino authors of romance in English.
[Read more ...]


%d bloggers like this:

By continuing to use the site, you agree to the use of cookies. more information

The cookie settings on this website are set to "allow cookies" to give you the best browsing experience possible. If you continue to use this website without changing your cookie settings or you click "Accept" below then you are consenting to this.